Hedging Market Risks Using Volatility Estimators-Are Sophisticated Methods Better?

Previously, we elaborated on why hedging is an important tool for risk management. We illustrated the importance of hedging with examples from the commodity, mortgage back securities, and foreign exchange markets.

A recent paper [1] evaluated the hedging effectiveness of various range-based volatility estimators. Among them, we can find the commonly used GARCH model.

Generalized AutoRegressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity (GARCH) is a statistical model used in analyzing time-series data where the variance error is believed to be serially autocorrelated. GARCH models assume that the variance of the error term follows an autoregressive moving average process.

Although Generalized AutoRegressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity (GARCH) models can be used in the analysis of a number of different types of financial data, such as macroeconomic data, financial institutions typically use them to estimate the volatility of returns for stocks, bonds, and market indices. They use the resulting information to help determine pricing and judge which assets will potentially provide higher returns, as well as to forecast the returns of current investments to help in their asset allocation, hedging, risk management, and portfolio optimization decisions. Read more

The article concluded,

The study is based on weekly data from January 2000 to December 2016 for six markets, including crude oil, gold, silver, natural gas, S&P 500, and NIFTY 50. The performance of hedge ratios estimated with various methods is evaluated with variance and semi-variance as the measures. The empirical results indicate that there is no specific econometric method, which outperforms the others consistently and significantly. The rolling OLS and BEKK GARCH methods are more efficient for estimating the optimal hedge ratio as compared to the other methods. The hedge ratios estimated with range-based models are not as efficient as those estimated with returns-based models are. More importantly, there is no significant difference in the variance/semi-variance of the naïve or rolling OLS based portfolios when compared to the other best-performing portfolios. The results are in line with some previous studies, which suggested that the simple naïve and OLS methods perform as well as the other more complex and sophisticated methods, if not better than them. The range-based methods are no exception to these general findings.

Briefly, simple hedging methods work as well as other more complex and sophisticated ones.

 

References

[1]  V. Pandy, V. Vipul,  Hedging performance of range-based volatility estimators, Journal of Business and Economic Studies, 2020

Further questions

What's your question? Ask it in the discussion forum

Have an answer to the questions below? Post it here or in the forum

LATEST NEWSMinovia Therapeutics to Present at Biotech Showcase on Tuesday, January 10, 2023
Minovia Therapeutics to Present at Biotech Showcase on Tuesday, January 10, 2023

Company to be in San Francisco January 8-12, 2023, during 41st Annual J.P. Morgan Health Care Conference WOBURN, Mass. and HAIFA, Israel, Jan. 03, 2023 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Minovia Therapeutics, a clinical-stage global biotechnology company, today announced that the Company will be presenting at the Biotech…

More news
LATEST NEWSGloom and boom: Fund managers’ top picks for 2023
Gloom and boom: Fund managers’ top picks for 2023

King Dollar’s reign (definitely) coming to an end, bonds bouncing and emerging markets rising again are just some of the trades international money managers are betting on in 2023. Sky-high inflation and the global gut-punch of nearly 300 central bank interest rate hikes over the…

More news
LATEST NEWSNew Prospective Study Evaluates the Accuracy of Masimo SpHb® Noninvasive and Continuous Hemoglobin Monitoring During Elective Cesarean Section
New Prospective Study Evaluates the Accuracy of Masimo SpHb® Noninvasive and Continuous Hemoglobin Monitoring During Elective Cesarean Section

Masimo SpHb Demonstrated “Clinically Acceptable Accuracy” of Hemoglobin Measurement, Even at Low Hemoglobin Levels NEUCHATEL, Switzerland — Masimo (NASDAQ: MASI) today announced the findings of a prospective study published in the Egyptian Journal of Anesthesia in which Dr. Mohamed Ibrahim Beleta and colleagues at Cairo…

More news
LATEST NEWSGensource Potash Announces First Closing of Non-Brokered Private Placement and TVR
Gensource Potash Announces First Closing of Non-Brokered Private Placement and TVR

NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION TO U.S. NEWS WIRE SERVICES OR DISSEMINATION IN THE UNITED STATES SASKATOON, Saskatchewan & LONDON — Gensource Potash Corporation (“Gensource” or the “Company”) (AIM/TSXV: GSP), a fertilizer development company focused on sustainable potash production, today announced that on December 30, 2022, it…

More news
LATEST NEWSSouth Korea fines Tesla $2.2 million for exaggerating driving range of EVs
South Korea fines Tesla $2.2 million for exaggerating driving range of EVs
More news

Leave a Reply