How Negative Interest Rates Affect Derivative Pricing Models

As negative interest rates started popping up around the world, quantitative analysts and traders have been asking a mundane but fundamental question: How to price trillions of dollars of financial instruments when their complex pricing models don’t work with negative numbers?

Intuitively, we would say that negative interest rates will affect the prices of interest-rate sensitive instruments such as interest rate swaps and swaptions the most. Indeed, Bloomberg recently elaborated:

The issues are most apparent in the market for interest-rate swaps. (This market allows professional investors to lock in interest rates and lets speculators bet on whether rates on bonds or loans will rise or fall.) That’s because the Black 76 model, the main tool to price options for interest-rate derivatives, and its variants are so-called log-normal forward models. For those who aren’t math nerds, it can essentially be boiled down to this: the formula breaks because it requires users to calculate a logarithm, and a logarithm of a negative number is undefined, or meaningless. Read more

derivative valuation derivative pricing of financial derivatives

As far as equity derivatives are concerned, the impact will not be as dramatic as with interest-rate sensitive instruments. However, some subtleties in the mathematical approaches can still have an impact on the accuracy of equity-derivative valuation models.

Derivatives traders in equities, on the other hand, have it relatively easy by comparison… sub-zero risk-free rates can cause “approximation errors” for certain kinds of American-style options, which may lead them to become mispriced compared with those used in Europe. Take an American call option on a stock without dividends, for example. Its value will “only equal the European option when the risk-free rate is positive”

Specifically, when we price an American call option, we often argue that if the underlying stock pays no dividend, then it’s never optimal to exercise earlier, i.e. the price of an American call option is equal to its European counterpart.

To see this, recall that there exists a lower bound for an American call option on a non-dividend paying stock [1]:

derivative valuation of equity derivative pricing model

                 where C denotes the price of an American call option

                 S0 is the stock price

                 K is the strike price

                T  is the time to maturity

                r  is the risk-free interest rate

From this equation, it follows that when r> 0, C >= S0-K. This means that the American call’s price is always greater than its intrinsic value, therefore it’s never optimal to exercise before maturity.

However, when r<=0, the above condition will no longer be true, and the American call option can be exercised earlier. This will impact the mathematical models that price American options.

 

References

[1] J.C. Hull, Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives, 9th Edition, 2018

Further questions

What's your question? Ask it in the discussion forum

Have an answer to the questions below? Post it here or in the forum

LATEST NEWSTexas lawmaker lobbies for 3rd graders to be trained to administer aid for gunshot wounds in the event of a school shooting, says report
Texas lawmaker lobbies for 3rd graders to be trained to administer aid for gunshot wounds in the event of a school shooting, says report

Texas Senator Barbara Gervin-Hawkins told CBS Austin that young lives could be saved with bleeding station training to help after a school shooting.

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSWagner group appears to U-turn on Bakhmut withdrawal, Russia keeps up missile attacks
Wagner group appears to U-turn on Bakhmut withdrawal, Russia keeps up missile attacks
Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSEmerging Markets Enter Into High-Anxiety Phase With Turkey Vote
Emerging Markets Enter Into High-Anxiety Phase With Turkey Vote

The potential shifts in the political landscape of emerging markets this year are putting investors on edge, with a slew of upcoming elections adding to pressure on flailing bonds, stocks and currencies.

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSRipple CEO Shows Excitement Over Support From XRP Community
Ripple CEO Shows Excitement Over Support From XRP Community
Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSThere's a record $5.3 trillion is cash on the sidelines as investors get more bearish on stocks. Here's why that could mean big gains ahead.
There's a record $5.3 trillion is cash on the sidelines as investors get more bearish on stocks. Here's why that could mean big gains ahead.

The recent surge of cash into money market funds eclipsed the $500 billion of fund inflows seen after the Lehman Brothers collapse in 2008.

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here

Leave a Reply