VIX Manipulation: Evidence from SPX Options and Market Data

Subscribe to newsletter

Market manipulation refers to intentional actions taken to distort the normal functioning of financial markets, often to benefit specific individuals or entities at the expense of others. These actions can include spreading false information, rigging prices, or creating artificial demand or supply. A notable example is the LIBOR manipulation scandal, where several major financial institutions colluded to manipulate the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR), a benchmark interest rate used globally to set borrowing costs for trillions of dollars in loans and derivatives. By submitting false rate estimates, these banks influenced LIBOR to their advantage, impacting everything from mortgages to corporate loans.

Reference [1] examined the alleged manipulation of VIX, the volatility index. Market observers claimed that unidentified manipulators, aiming to influence the index, submitted aggressive orders in out-of-the-money (OTM) S&P 500 index options that are included in the VIX calculation. According to these allegations, manipulators profited from these artificial price movements through positions in VIX-related products such as options and futures.

The paper utilized three datasets obtained from the CBOE, covering the period from January 2011 to August 2018, to conduct the study. The author pointed out,

Subscribe to newsletter https://harbourfrontquant.beehiiv.com/subscribe Newsletter Covering Trading Strategies, Risk Management, Financial Derivatives, Career Perspectives, and More

Based on detailed investor-class level data for the period from January 2011 until August 2018, I examine several relations to identify potential manipulative activity during the VIX settlement period. I show that investors within the customer group (i.e., hedge funds and money managers) move prices during the special opening auction and align their price impact to profit from the resulting settlement deviations. Furthermore, I find that customers spread their trading volume across the options used in the calculation of the settlement value proportional to the respective VIX sensitivity. This is consistent with the optimal trading strategy to manipulate the VIX, as shown by Griffin and Shams (2018). Finally, customers’ exposure adjustments the day before expiration predict price movements during the subsequent special opening auction. This suggests that customers anticipate the direction of the VIX movements, which is consistent with manipulation.

Over the sample period from June 2011 to August 2018, settlement deviations caused market distortions that amount to $4.7 billion. Customers benefit from these deviations and earn $91 million over the respective period. These results stress the vulnerability of the VIX settlement process in its current form.

In summary, the author provided evidence supporting claims of VIX manipulation.

This article contributes to improving market transparency and functionality. Let us know what you think in the comments below or in the discussion forum.

References

[1] Manuel Leininger, Essays on Derivatives Markets, University of Konstanz, 2024, Chapter 1

Subscribe to newsletter https://harbourfrontquant.beehiiv.com/subscribe Newsletter Covering Trading Strategies, Risk Management, Financial Derivatives, Career Perspectives, and More

Further questions

What's your question? Ask it in the discussion forum

Have an answer to the questions below? Post it here or in the forum

LATEST NEWSBrookfield Business Partners Reports 2024 Year End Results
Brookfield Business Partners Reports 2024 Year End Results

BROOKFIELD, News, Jan. 31, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Brookfield Business Partners (NYSE: BBU, BBUC; TSX: BBU.UN, BBUC) announced today financial results for the year ended December 31, 2024. “Our business had another successful year in 2024. We generated over $2 billion from our capital recycling initiatives,…

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSIndia Says China Dominance is A Risk to Clean Energy Transition
India Says China Dominance is A Risk to Clean Energy Transition

India’s government flagged China’s dominance in clean energy gear as a potential risk to its low-carbon transition, advocating a more diverse global supply chain and targeted incentives.

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSAbraSilver Announces $48.4 Million Financing, Comprised of $21.8 Million “Bought Deal” Public Offering and $26.6 Million Concurrent Private Placement of Common Shares
AbraSilver Announces $48.4 Million Financing, Comprised of $21.8 Million “Bought Deal” Public Offering and $26.6 Million Concurrent Private Placement of Common Shares

NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION TO U.S. NEWS WIRE SERVICES OR FOR DISSEMINATION IN THE UNITED STATES THE SHELF PROSPECTUS SUPPLEMENT, THE CORRESPONDING BASE SHELF PROSPECTUS AND ANY AMENDMENT TO THE DOCUMENTS IS ACCESSIBLE THROUGH SEDAR+ OR WILL BE ACCESSIBLE THROUGH SEDAR+ WITHIN 2 BUSINESS DAYS, AS…

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSAlgonquin Power & Utilities Corp. Announces Leadership Transition
Algonquin Power & Utilities Corp. Announces Leadership Transition

Rod West appointed Chief Executive Officer, succeeding Chris Huskilson OAKVILLE, Ontario — Algonquin Power & Utilities Corp. (TSX/NYSE: AQN) (“AQN”, “Algonquin” or the “Company”) announced today that Rod West will join AQN as Chief Executive Officer, effective March 7, 2025. Chris Huskilson will step down…

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSCiveo Announces Quarterly Dividend
Civeo Announces Quarterly Dividend

HOUSTON & CALGARY, Alberta — Civeo Corporation (NYSE:CVEO) announced today that its board of directors has declared a quarterly cash dividend of $0.25 per common share, payable on March 17, 2025 to shareholders of record as of close of business on February 24, 2025. For…

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here

Leave a Reply