What is the Substantive Audit Approach

An audit approach defines the strategy that auditors use to conduct an audit. Usually, auditors use a specific audit approach for every audit assignment based on several factors. Among these approaches, some may apply to clients or engagements in different industries. One of these includes the substantive audit approach, also known as the vouching approach.

What is the Substantive Audit Approach?

The substantive audit approach is a strategy that auditors use that primarily focuses on substantive procedures. This approach requires auditors to perform more work. However, it also allows them to test the subject matter in more depth. The substantive audit approach is the opposite of the system-based audit approach, which relies on internal controls.

Add your business to our business directory https://harbourfronts.com/directory/ Add your business. Also check out other businesses in the directory

Auditors use the substantive audit approach to verify balances and transactions in more detail. Usually, auditors assess the client’s internal control systems first. If they believe they cannot rely on the systems in place at the client, they will choose the substantive audit approach. In other words, this approach is beneficial when auditors believe the client’s internal control systems to be inefficient.

How does the Substantive Audit Approach work?

As mentioned, the substantive audit approach begins with an assessment of a client’s internal control systems. Usually, auditors do so to decide on the audit strategy to use. If a client’s internal control systems are reliable, auditors will prefer the system-based approach to audits. On the other hand, if they can’t trust those systems, they will use the substantive audit approach.

The substantive audit approach requires more work from auditors. Since auditors cannot rely on the client’s internal control systems, they will seek to cover the audit risks through substantive procedures. These procedures primarily include a test of details and substantive audit procedures. With this approach, auditors will select a larger sample of events and transactions and test them.

The substantive approach to audits focuses on testing balances and transactions in detail. It is why it is also known as the vouching approach to audit. This approach may apply to both internal and external audits. Auditors perform thorough vouching by looking at supporting documents for all items tested. In case the client’s internal controls are inefficient, this approach can be highly effective.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of the Substantive Audit Approach?

The substantive approach to audits allows auditors to test balances and transactions in detail. By doing so, they can cover a significantly higher portion of audit risks compared to other approaches. However, that is still subject to sampling risks. This approach is also one of the traditional approaches to audit and is easy to understand. Substantive audits are beneficial when auditors can’t rely on the client’s internal controls.

The substantive audit approach has some drawbacks, though. The primary one of these includes more work performed by auditors. Since this approach focuses on larger volumes of testing, it significantly increases auditors’ workloads. Similarly, the substantive audit approach is not risk-focused. Some auditors consider it outdated due to the number of better alternative audit approaches available.

Conclusion

The substantive audit approach is a strategy that auditors use when the client’s internal control systems are unreliable. This approach focuses on a higher volume of testing and vouching. Due to this, auditors will perform more work to cover the audit risks associated with an audit engagement. However, this approach is more traditional, and there are better alternatives available.

Further questions

What's your question? Ask it in the discussion forum

Have an answer to the questions below? Post it here or in the forum

LATEST NEWSInvestors are pouring cash into crypto at the highest level in 6 months as risk appetite returns and bitcoin wraps up best January since 2013
Investors are pouring cash into crypto at the highest level in 6 months as risk appetite returns and bitcoin wraps up best January since 2013

Investors made a large shift away from short-bets on bitcoin last week. The token's price has climbed about 40% in January.

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSIndia’s Adani Group plans independent audit of group companies- Mint
India’s Adani Group plans independent audit of group companies- Mint

India’s Adani Group is planning to hire one of the “big six” accounting firms to assess its corporate governance and audit practices following allegations of fraud by short-selling firm Hindenburg, Mint newspaper reported on Monday. The audit will be commissioned after the group’s unit, Adani…

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSRemote workers are losing ground in the work from home wars: More than half of employees went into the office last week
Remote workers are losing ground in the work from home wars: More than half of employees went into the office last week

Good news for business leaders, not so much for the work from home die hards.

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSThe sizzling rally in stocks is nearing its end as investors are about to realize a recession has merely been postponed, JPMorgan says
The sizzling rally in stocks is nearing its end as investors are about to realize a recession has merely been postponed, JPMorgan says

Markets are pricing in a 59% chance of a recession, down from 90% in October. But even that could be too optimistic, JPMorgan said.

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSBuzzFeed writers react with a mix of disappointment and excitement at news that AI-generated content is coming to the website
BuzzFeed writers react with a mix of disappointment and excitement at news that AI-generated content is coming to the website

The decision to use tech from ChatGPT maker OpenAI to produce content is part of BuzzFeed's broader cost-cutting strategy in a challenging economy.

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here

Leave a Reply