Is Cointegration the Best Method for Pairs Trading?

Pairs trading is a classic “market-neutral” trading strategy. Previously, we highlighted an article that claims that cointegration is a superior method for selecting pairs [1].

On the same topic, Reference [2] examined more pair selection methods. Specifically, it investigated the following approaches,

  • Distance: Pairs are identified by using distance metrics. This is perhaps the simplest approach.
  • Cointegration: Cointegration tests are applied to identify pairs and generate signals.
  • Copula: Trading signals are generated by relative value drawn from estimating the joint probability distribution of returns.
  • Time series: Focuses on generating trading signals by time series analysis. Often ignores formation period.
  • Stochastic: Uses stochastic control theory in determining value and policy functions for this portfolio problem. Ignores formation period.
  • Other: Experimental frameworks with less supporting literature. These approaches include machine learning and principal component analysis.

It concluded, contrary to Reference [1], that the best method for selecting pairs is the distance method. Cointegration is the second-best one only. Note that the results are applicable to the Finnish stock market.

This thesis confirms the assumptions made in previous literature about what types of pairs are suitable for pairs trading. When pair formation is limited to allow only pairs consisting of companies from the same industry, distance-based and cointegration-based selection favors pairs formed of different share classes of one company. An example of this is Orion Class A- Orion Class B. Such pairs provide more trading opportunities than other types of pairs (e.g. Stora Enso – UPM).

Although 2 articles are contradictory, we believe that:

  • Simple methods work best. There is no need for more complex ones. Instead of using complex, advanced pair selection methods, one should focus on the strategy robustness, especially on minimizing divergence risks.
  • Ideally the pairs should consist of different share classes on the same underlying. If different share classes don’t exist, then the pairs should consist of stocks in the same industries. If we generalize this to futures markets, then trading futures on the same commodities would make sense.

References

[1] N. Huck and K. Afawubo, Pairs trading and selection methods: is cointegration superior?, Applied Economics, 47:6, 599-613, 2015

[2] S. Kohvakka, Pairs trading revisited – the case of OMX Helsinki, Lappeenranta-Lahti University of Technology LUT, 2020

Further questions

What's your question? Ask it in the discussion forum

Have an answer to the questions below? Post it here or in the forum

LATEST NEWSHow I went from working on cruise ships to taking more than 20 a year as a guest — and make a living doing it
How I went from working on cruise ships to taking more than 20 a year as a guest — and make a living doing it

J. Alexander was working on cruise ships when he started his YouTube account, "The Shiplife." Now he says his work "is literally vacationing."

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSG7 to vow diversifying of supply chains, filling bank regulatory gaps -draft
G7 to vow diversifying of supply chains, filling bank regulatory gaps -draft

Finance leaders of the Group of Seven (G7) advanced economies set a year-end deadline for launching a new scheme to diversify global supply chains, and vowed to address regulatory gaps in the banking system, according to a final draft of their communique seen by Reuters.…

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSData of 237,000 US government employees breached
Data of 237,000 US government employees breached

WASHINGTON — The personal information of 237,000 current and former federal government employees has been exposed in a data breach at the U.S. Transportation Department (USDOT), sources briefed on the matter said on Friday. The breach hit systems for processing TRANServe transit benefits that reimburse…

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSEro Copper Files Technical Report for the Xavantina Operations
Ero Copper Files Technical Report for the Xavantina Operations

VANCOUVER, British Columbia, May 12, 2023 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Ero Copper Corp. (TSX: ERO, NYSE: ERO) (“Ero” or the “Company”) is pleased to announce the filing of its Technical Report for the Xavantina Operations related to the increase in mineral reserves and mineral resources and…

Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here
LATEST NEWSStellantis, LGES implementing 'contingency plans' for battery plant in Canada
Stellantis, LGES implementing 'contingency plans' for battery plant in Canada
Stay up-to-date with the latest news - click here

Leave a Reply